You are here

Home » Content

Faith or Reason? The Shi’ite Tradition of Political Ideas in the Light of the Theological Debate

Journal Name:

  • European Journal of Economic and Political Studies

Publication Year:

  • 2010

Key Words:

Author Name
Abstract (2. Language): 
The 11th February, 2010 marked the commemoration of the thirty-first anniversary of the Islamic revolution in Iran. In 1979, the Shi’ite Islamists assumed power there. Since then, Shi’a politics has played a dominant role in the development of both Iran and several other countries in the Middle East. This has included the restructuring of the political map in Iraq since the fall of the dictator Saddam Hussein, which has meant that Shi’ite political parties and leading Shi’ite scribes play a decisive role in the politics of the country, as well as the dominant role of Hizbollah in the Lebanon. Shi’ite groups in a number of countries supporting a Sunni majority have also moved more to the fore. The development that has taken place in Shi’a dominated areas over the last three decades is seen to be based on a Shi’ite tradition of political ideas which has emerged during the 1400 year history of Shi’a Islam. One feature of this development has been the predominant role of the scribes in politics, and their regard for a tradition of political ideas which excludes any sharp distinction between the state/politics and religion. The question is whether this picture agrees with the view held by Shi’ite thinkers regarding the relationship between the state and religion. A backward glance at Shi’a history reveals that no shared view exists among Shi’ite scholars on the subject of politics and this particular relationship. Seen from a history of ideas perspective, it is not possible to speak about an unchanged metahistorical-political discourse which must have coloured all political thought throughout Shi’a history. We find, rather, a broad spectrum of different views among Shi’ite scholars. Another question is whether, aside from the influence of social, historical and political structures and relations, a closer look should also be taken at the importance of the tradition of theological interpretation. Did, for example, the view of the relationship between faith and reason play any part in this context?
Bookmark/Search this post with
FULL TEXT (PDF): 
PDF icon arastirmax-faith-or-reason-shiite-tradition-political-ideas-light-theological-debate.pdf
  • 1
143-161
  • English

REFERENCES

References: 

Al-e Seyyed Ghafur, Seyyed Mohsen (2007). Jaygah-e siyasi-ye alem-e dini dar do
maktabe akhbari va usuli (The political position of religious scholars in the two
Akhbari and Usuli schools of fiqh ), Bustan-e ketab publishers; Qom.
‘Amid Zanjani, ‘Abbas’ali (1989). Feqhe siyasi, vol. 1-2, Teheran; Amir kabir.
Araki, Mohammad ’Ali, (1993). al-Makasib al-muharrama, Qum; Dar rahe haqq.
Aqajari, Hashem (2002). “Farayand-e tahavvull va takamol-e andishe va rafter-e âleman
va faqihan-e Shi’i-ya emami”, Aftab 2002:20.
Astarabadi, Muhammed Amin (No date). Fawai’d al-madina, Qom; Dar al-nashr li ahl
al-baiyt.
Firahi, Davood (1999). Qodrat, danesh va mashro’iyyat dar eslam, Teheran; Nashre Ney.
Feyz Kashani, Muhsen (1999). Dah resaleh muhaqqeqq bozorg Feyze Kashani, ed.
Ja’fariyan, Rasoul, Isfahan; Markaz-e tahqiqat-e elmi dini-ye amir al-mu’menin.
Gharavi Tabrizi, Mirza ‘Ali (1991). al-Tanqih fi sharhi al-‘urwatolwuthqa. Al-Ijtihad wa
al-taqlid, taqrirat abhath Sayyid Abulqasim Mousavi al-Kho’i, 3 ed. Qum.
Hairi, Abdul-Hadi (1988). Nakhustin rouyarouihaye andishegarane Iran ba do roye-ye
tamaddune borjoazi-ye gharb (The Early Encounters of the Iranian Thinkers with the
Two-Sided Civilization of Western Bourgeoisie), Teheran; Amir Kabir.
Hairi Yazdi, Mahdi (1995). Hekmat va hokoumat, London; Shadi Publishing.
Kadivar, Jamileh (2000). Tahavvule goftemane siyasi-ye shi’e dar Iran (The Development
of Shi’ite Political Discourse in Iran), Teheran; Tarhe-e nô.
Kadivar, Mohsen (1999). Nazariyeha-ye dowlat dar feqh-e shi’eh, Teheran; Nashre ney.
Kazemi, Mousavi, Ahmad (1990). ”Dorehaye tarikhi-ye tadvine va tahavvole feqh-e shi’a”,
Majalleh tahqiqate eslami, 1990:1-2.
Montazeri, Hussein Ali (1988-1991). Dirasat fi wilayat al-faqih wa fiqh al-dawla alislamiyya,
4 vol. Qum, al-Markaz al-’alami lildirasat al-islamiyya va dar al-fikr.
Mousavi al-Khomeini, Ruhollah (1983-1993). Sahife-ye noor, vol. 20-21, Teheran.
Mughniyya, Mohammad Javad (1979). al-Khomeini va al-dawula al-islamiyya,, Beirut; Dar
al-ilm lilmala’in.
Na’ini, Mohammad Hussein (1955). Tanbîh al-umma wa tanzîh al-milla, 3 ed., Teheran;
Amir kabir.
Mohammad Fazlhashemi
160
Al-Sadr, Seyyed Muhammed Baqer (1980). Hamrah ba tahavvule ijtihad, persian
translation Akbar Thabout, no place given; Roozbeh.
Sachedina, Abdulaziz Abdulhussein (1998). Islamic Messianism: The idea of Mahdi in
Twelver Shi’ism, Albany: State University of New York Press.
Seyyed Murtada (1986). Risala al-amal ma’a as-sultan, Qom; Matbat Sayyid al-shuhada.
Shams al-din, Mohammad Mahdi, (1992). Nizam al-hakam va idara fi al-islam, 3 ed. Qom;
Dar al-thiqafa.
—, (1994). Fi al-ijtima’ al-siyasi al-islami, 2 ed. Qom; Dar al-thiqafa.
Tabataba’i, Sayyed Mohammad Hussien (2007). al-Mizan fi tafsir al-Qur’an, 22 ed., vol. 5.
Qom; Daftare entesharate eslami.
European Journal of Economic and Political Studies
161

Thank you for copying data from http://www.arastirmax.com