You are here

TOPLULUK MEVZUATI ÇERÇEVESİNDE ANKARA ANTLAŞMASININ ETKİLERİ

EFFECTS OF ANKARA AGREEMENT WITHIN THE COMMUNITY LEGAL ORDER

Journal Name:

Publication Year:

Author Name
Abstract (2. Language): 
The achieved rights regarding free movement -of workers- and social security for Turkish citizens in the European Union have a progressive legal background and constitute a major role within the Community legal order. This paper presents the main legal steps related to free movement of workers and social security rights of Turkish citizens in the context of Association Agreements, Ankara Agreement, Additional Protocol and Decisions 1/80 and 3/80 of Association Council. Study also presents the distinctive situation of Turkish workers as per the other third country nationals by illustrating the relatively better position of Turkish workers in European Union is mostly derives from the decisions of Association Council and case laws of the European Court of Justice. Finally study suggests that although Turkish workers are privileged, there are still many issues regarding the principle of equal treatment which have to be solved.
Abstract (Original Language): 
Avrupa Birliğinde Türk vatandaşları için işçilerin serbest dolaşımı ve sosyal güvenlik alanlarında elde edilen haklar, sürekli gelişen bir yasal arka plana sahip olup topluluğun yasal düzeninde önemli bir yer teşkil etmektedir. Bu yazı, Türk vatandaşlarının sosyal güvenlik hakları ile işçilerin serbest dolaşımı hakkındaki temel yasal düzenlemeleri Ankara Anlaşması, Katma Protokol ile Ortaklık Konseyinin 1/80 ve 3/80 sayılı kararları çerçevesinde ele alacaktır. Bu çalışma, Türk işçilerinin Ortaklık Konseyi kararları ve Avrupa Adalet Divanının içtihat hukukundan ileri gelen Avrupa Birliği içindeki göreceli iyi konumunu ve bu sayede diğer üçüncü ülke vatandaşlarından farklı durumuna da değinmektedir. Son olarak çalışma, Türk işçilerinin imtiyazlı olmalarına rağmen hâlâ eşit muamele ilkesiyle ilgili çözülmesi gereken birçok sorunun olduğunu öne sürmektedir.
151-171

REFERENCES

References: 

Books
Angelopoulou, O. (2000) “Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the European Convention of Human Rights
and Social Security Benefits” in International Impact upon Social Security, D. Pieters (ed.),
Kluwer.
Arnull, A. (1990) The General Principles of EEC Law and the Individual, Leicester.
Arnull/ Dashwood/Ross/ Wyatt (2000) EU Law, Sweet & Maxwell 4th ed.
Barendt and Wikeley (1995) The Law of Social Security, Butterworhts, 4th ed.
Barnard, C. (1996) Employment Law, Wiley.
Bercusson, B. (1996) European Labour Law, Butterworths.
Bernard, N. (1996) “What Are the Purposes of EC Discrimination Law?” in Discrimination Law,
Janet Dine & Bob Watt (eds.), Longman.
Carlier, J. (1999) “Article 39 and Article 12 of the EC Treaty” in Social Security in Europe, (Conference
“The EC Treaty and Regulation 1408/71”), Vienna.
Cholewinski , R. (1996) “The Rights of Non-EC Immigrant Workers and Their Families in EC
Countries of Employment: a Case for Integration”, in Discrimination Law, Janet Dine & Bob
Watt (eds.), Longman.
Craig, P. and de Burca, G. (2002) EU Law: Text, Cases, and Materials, Oxford, 3rd edn.
Deakin, S. and Morris, G.S. (1999) Labour Law, Butterworths, 2nd ed.
Falkner, G. (1998) European Union Social Policy in the 1990s, Routledge.
Gaja, G. (1994) “The Protection of Human Rights under the Maastricht Treaty”, in Institutional
Dynamics of European Integration, D. Curtin & T. Heukels (eds.), Martinis Nijhoff.
Hâlibronner, K. (2000) Immigration and Asylum Law and Policy of the EU, Kluwer.
Hervey, T.(1998) European Social Law and Policy, Longman.
Holloway, J. (1981) Social Policy Harmonisation in the European Community, Gower Publishing.
Jepsen, M. and Meulders, D. (2002) “The Individualizations of Rights in Social Protection Systems”,
in Labour Market and Social Protection Reforms in International Perspective, H. Sarfati and
G. Bonoli (ed.), Ashgate.
Kent, P. (2001) Law of the EU, Longman, 3rd ed..
Kent, P. (2000) EU Law, Sweet & Maxwell, 2nd ed.
Koray, S. (1999) Study on Migrations: the case of Turkey, Lit.
Macleod, I.; Henry, I. and Hyett, S. (1996) The External Relations of the European Communities,
Oxford University Press.
Martin, D. & Guild, E. (1996) Free Movement of Persons in the EU, Butterworths.
Martin, P. (1991) The Unfinished Story: Turkish Labour Migration to Western Europe, ILO.
McGoldrick, D. (1997) International Relations Law of the European Union, Longman.
O’Keeffe, D. (1982) “The Scope and Content of Social Security Regulation in EC Law” in Essays in
European Law and Integration, D.O’Keeffe and H. Schermers, Kluwer.
Pakaslahti, J. (2000) Social Security Vision of the EU in International Impact Upon Social
Security, D. Pieters (edt.), Kluwer Law International.
Peers, S. (1999) “Human Rights and the Third Pillar” in P. Alson (ed.) The EU and Human Rights,
Oxford.
Pennings, F. (2001) Introduction to European Social Security Law, Kluwer Law, 3rd Ed.
Pieters, D. and Nickless, J. (1998) Pathways for Social Protection in Europe, Helsinki.
Prechal, S. (1995) Directives in EC Law, Oxford.
Pugliese (1996) “Italy Between Emigration and Immigration and the Problems of Citizenship” in Citizenship,
Nationality and Migration in Europe, D. Cesarani and M. Fulbrook (eds.), Routledge.
Rudden, B. and Phelan, D. (1997) Basic Community Cases, Oxford, 2nd ed..
Sarfati, H. (2002) “Labour Market and Social Protection Policies: Linkages and Interactions”, in
Labour Market and Social Protection Reforms in International Perspective, H. Sarfati and
G. Bonoli (ed.), Ashgate.
Schermers, H. (1982) “The Internal Effect of Community Treaty-Making”, in Essays in European
Law and Integration, D.O’Keeffe and H. Schermers (Eds.), Kluwer.
Teague, P. (1989) The European Community: The Social Dimension, Cranfield School of Management.
Weatherill, S. (2000) Cases & Materials on EC Law, Blackstone, 5th ed..
Weiler, J. (1991) “Thou Shall Not Oppress a Stranger: on the Judicial Protection of the Human
Rights of Non-EC Nationals”, in Free Movement of Persons in Europe, H. Schermers…[et
al.] (eds.), Martiunus Nijhoff.
White, R. (1999) EC Social Security Law, Longman.
Articles
Barrett, G. (2003) “Family Matters: EC Law and Third-Country Family Members”, 40 CML Rev.,
369-421.
Bercusson, B, and [et al.] (1997) “A Manifesto for Social Europe”, 3 ELJ, 189-205.
Bulterman, M. (1997) Case commentary on Taflan Met, 34 CML Rev., 1497-1507.
Burrows, N. (1994) “The Rights of Turkish Workers in the Member States”, 19 (3) E.L.Rev.
Cheyne, I., (1994) “International Agreements and the European Community Legal System”, 19
(6) E.L. Rev.
Cornelisse, P and Goudswaard, K. (2002) “On the Convergence of Social Protection Systems in the
EU”, 3 International Social Security Review, Vol. 55, 3-17.
Cornelissen, R. (1996) “The Principle of Territoriality and the Community Regulations on Social
Security”, 33 CML Rev., 439-471.
Cremona, M. (1995) “Citizens of Third Countries: Movement and Employment of Migrant Workers
Within the EU”, 2 LIEI.
Favell and Geddes (1999) “European Integration, Immigrations and the Nation State”, Working
Papers of the Robert Schuman Centre.
Gagliardi, F. (1999) “The Right of Individuals to Invoke the Provisions of Mixed Agreements Before
the National Courts: a New Message from Luxembourg”, 24 EL.Rev., 276- 292.
Giesen, R. (1999) Case commentary on Decker and Kohll, 36 CML Rev., 841-850.
Harvey, C. (2003) “Justice, Migration and Human Rights”, 23 Oxford Journals of Legal Studies,
147-156.
Hedemann-Robinson, M. (2001) “An Overview of Recent Legal Developments at Community
Level in relation to Third Country Nationals Resident within the EU, with Particular Reference
to the Case Law of the ECJ”, 38 CML Rev., 525-586.
Johnson, E. and O’Keeffee, D. (1994) “From Discrimination to Obstacles to Free Movement: Recent
Developments Concerning the Free Movement of Workers 1989-1994”, 31 CML Rev.,
1313-1346.
Laske, C. (1993) “The Impact of the Single European Market on Social Protection for Migrant
Workers”, 30 CML Rev., 515-539.
McLaren, L.M. (2000) “Turkey’s Eventual Membership of the EU: Turkish Elite Perspectives on
the Issue”, 38 JCMS, 117-129.
Moore, M. (1998) “Freedom of Movement and Migrant Workers’ Social Security: An Overview of
the Court’s Jurisprudence 1992-1997”, 35 CML Rev., 409-457.
Neuwahl, N. (1996) “Shared Powers or Combined Incompetence? More on Mixity”, 33 CML Rev.,
667-687.
Neuwahl, N. (1996) “The European Parliament and Association Council Decisions: The Example of
Decision 1/95 of the EC/Turkey Association Council”, 33 CML Rev., 51-68.
Oliveira, A.C. (2002) “Workers and Other Persons: Step-by-step from Movement to Citizenship-
Case law 1995-2001”, 39 CML Rev., 2002, 77-127.
Peers, S. (1995) “An Ever Closer Waiting Room?” , 32 CML Rev.
Peers, S. (1996) “Living in Sin: Legal Integration in the EC-Turkey Customs Union”, 3 European
Journal of International Law, 411-430.
Peers, S. (1999) Case Commentary on Akman, 36 CML Rev.
Peers, S. (1996) Case Commentary on Bozkurt, 33 CML Rev.
Peers, S. (1999) “Social Security Equality for Turkish Nationals”, 24 EL Rev.
Peers, S. (1996) “Towards Equality: Actual and Potential Rights of Third-Country Nationals in the
EU” , 33 CML Rev.
Peers, S. (1998) “Building Fortress Europe: The Development of EU Migration Law”, 35 CML
Rev., 1235-1272.
Peers, S. (1997) “Equality, Free Movement and Social Security”, 22(4), E.L.Rev., 342-351.
Schermers, H. (1991) Commentary on case Sevince, 28 CML Rev., 183-189.
Scheuner, U. (1975) “Fundamental Rights in European Community Law and in National Constitutional
Law”, 12 CML Rev.
Steiner, J. (1992) “Social Security for EC Migrants”, Journal of Social Welfare & Family Law.
Verschueren, H. (1997) “EC Social Security Coordination Excluding Third Country Nationals: Still
in Line with Fundamental Rights After Gaygusuz Judgment?”, 34 (4) CML Rev.
Watson, P. (1997) “Social Policy after Maastricht”, 33 CML Rev.
Webber, A. (1994) Case commentary on Kus, 31 CML Rev.
Case Law
Case C-210/97, Akman, [1998] ECR I-7519.
Case 10/78, Belbouab, [1978] ECR 1915.
Case C-1/97, Birden, [1998] ECR I-7747.
Case C-434/93, Bozkurt, [1995] ECR I-1475.
Case 87/75, Bresciani, [1976] ECR 129.
Case 45/86, Commission v Council, [1987] ECR 1493.
Case C-12/86, Demirel, [1987] ECR 3719.
Case 287/83, Diatta, [1985] ECR 567.
Case C-386/95, Eker, [1997] ECR I-2697.
Case C-416/96, El-Yassini, [1999] ECR I-1209.
Case 329-97, Ergat, [2000] ECR I-1487.
Case C-355/93, Eroglu, [1994] ECR I-5113.
Case C-98/96, Ertanir, [1997] ECR I-5179.
Case C-65/98, Eyup, [2000] ECR I-4747.
Case C-190/98, Graf, [2000] ECR I-493.
Case C-36/96, Gunaydin, [1997] ECR I-5143.
Case 181/73, Haegeman, [1974] ECR 449.
Case 75/63, Hoekstra, [1964] ECR 177.
Case 351/95, Kadiman, [1997] ECR I-2133.
Case 139/85, Kempf, [1986] ECR 1741.
Case 40/76, Kermaschek, [1976] ECR 1669.
Case C-95/99, Khâlil, ECR-I 7413.
Case C-2/89, Kits, [1990] ECR I-1769.
Joined Cases C-102/98 and C-211/98, Kocak and Ors, [2000] ECR I-1287.
Joined cases 3, 4 and 6/76 , Kramer , [1976] ECR 1279.
Case C-103/94,Krid, [1995] ECR I-719.
Case 104/81, Kupferberg, [1982] ECR 3641
Case C-237/91, Kus, [1992] ECR I-6781.
Case C- 18/90, Kziber, [1991] ECR I-199.
Case 66/85, Lawrie-Blum, [1986] ECR, 2121.
Case 53/81, Levin, [1982] ECR 1035.
Case 60/85, Luijten, [1986] ECR 2365.
Case C-57/96, Meints, [1997] ECR I-6689.
Case 167/73, Merchant Seamen, [1974] ECR, 359.
Case 4/73, Nold, [1974] ECR 491.
Case 17/81, Pabst & Richarz, [1982] ECR 1331.
Case C-349/87, Parashi, [1991] ECR I-4501.
Joined Cases 267 to 269/81, Petrolifera, [1983] ECR 801.
Case 41/84, Pinna, [1986] ECR 1.
Case 270/80, Polydor, [1982] ECR 329
Ruling 1/78, Protection of Nuclear Materials, [1978] ECR 2151.
Case C- 227/89, Ronfeld, [1991] ECR I- 323.
Cases 117/76 and 16/77, Ruckdeschel, [1977] ECR 1753.
Case 149/77, Sabena, [1978] ECR 1365.
Case C-192/89, Sevince, [1990] ECR I-3461.
Case C-262/96, Surul, [1999] ECR-I 2685.
Case C-277/94, Taflan-Met, [1996] ECR I-4085.
Case 237/78, Toia, [1979] ECR 2645.
Case C-215/90, Twomey, [1992] ECR I-1823.
Case C-41/74, Van Duyn, [1974] ECR 1337.
Case 82/72, Walder, [1973] ECR 599.
Case 36/74, Walrave, [1974] ECR 1405.
Case 143/79, Walsh, [1980] ECR 1639.
Case C-37/89, Weiser, [1990] ECR I- 2395.
Case 14/68, Wilhelm, [1969] ECR 1.
Case C-58/93 ,Yousfi,[1994] ECR I- 1353.
Case 126/86, Zaera, [1987] ECR 3697.
Other Sources
Center for Turkish studies (ed.), Turkey and the EC, Leske Budrich, 1993.
European Commission, The European Community 1992 and Beyond, Luxembourg 1991.
European Commission, Judgments of the ECJ related to Social Security for Migrant Workers, a
Systematic survey, Luxembourg, 1995.
Hardy, R., Thorny issues for the EU, BBC, Friday, 13 December, 2002, 12:52 GMT, [http://news.
bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/2572531.stm] (08.06.2010)
ILPA Comments, available internet at: [http://www.ilpa.org.uk/submissions/residents.html]
(16.06.2010).
Mamak, M., Legal Aspects of the Customs Union between the EC and Turkey, Dissertation of
LLM in EC Law, Supervisor: S. Peers, University of Essex, 1998.
Mougenot, “Integration of Legally Resident TCN in the EU”, University of Essex, Dissertation,
LLM in EC Law, 1997.
Peers, S., “Free movement of people: an introduction, 1999”, [http://eurotext.ulster.ac.uk/policy/
people/eai19/eai19toc.html#x] (06.05.2003)
Vink, M., “Limits of European Citizenship: European Integration and Domestic Immigration Policies”,
[http://ideas.repec.org/p/erp/conweb/p0018.html], (10.06.2010).

Thank you for copying data from http://www.arastirmax.com