You are here

TÜRKİYE'DE TEKİLCİ KÜLTÜR HUKUKİLİK VE ARMAĞAN EKONOMiSi

Journal Name:

Publication Year:

Author NameUniversity of AuthorFaculty of Author
Abstract (2. Language): 
fiontradtcton dualin' of particularism versus unitersalism has significant outcorncs in Turker'. Panicularism nuv manifest itself in the ilttitudes in relations bctl'een diflbrcnt groupso r their nrctnbersa nd undcr lbnns of adoptiono l doubles tandards. nroral disinterest to\l'ards thc or.rtsider(s)l-a vouritism and politicat patronage. Expeclations arising from dcep-laving nonns ol'reciprocirr and colnplementarin' obsen'cd in interpcrsonal rclations suggest cullural background in Turke,v supports tlie gift econonlv and the notions of virtue ethics and "honour based moraliS'" rlitnessed in various circlcs in Turkev bolh havc their rools in accepted particularistic liabr lities.
157-208

REFERENCES

References: 

Adanrr. Opuz- "Eski Diin.ta'.t'o leni Bir BahS" -"Kuramsal Bir l)enene-",
Kitap: I-ll. Dokuz Evltil Ya1'rnal n. lzmir " 1997.
Barth. Fredrik. '-Role Dilemmas and Fathcr-Son Dominance in Middle
Eastern Kinship Svstems". Kin.ship qnd (-ulture. Edited h' Francis L K.
Hsu.A ldine PublishingC ompanr'C. hicago:l 97l iginde.
Baunrrind. Diana. "New Directions in Socialization Rcsearch". ,4mencan
P.s.vh'cr t I ogi.st-J ulv I 9tt0.
Bell. Daniel A.. "A Communitarian Critique of Authoritarianism -Thc
Case of Singapore": PoliticalTheor.v'. Vol. 2-5. No. l. Febman' 1997.
Benhabib. Se_rla. Situaling 'l'he Self -(iender, ('unnrunity und
Pttstmulerni.snitt r ('ontemporar.yF ,lhics-^P olit_vP ress.I 994.
Bierbraue. Giinter" ''Reactions to Violation of Normative Standarts: A
Cross-Cultural Analvsis of Shame and Guilt". Interntttiotrai .lournal of
Ps .vch o I o g,-- | 992 . 27( 2\.
Bodur, Muzafler r/c Ha)'at Kabasakal. "Lcadership Pattcrns in Turker".
Suna Kili'.ve, lrntapan -('unhuri.y'ete.l danan Rir IaSan- iginde. Bolazirri
UnivcrsitesYi a1'rnlan.is lanbul.l 99tt
Boldt. Edl'ard D.. "Struclural Tightness and Cross-Cultural Research".
.lournal uf Cro.:s-CulturalP s.tchologr.V'"o l. 9. No.2. June 1978.
Boldl. Edlard D.. Lancc W. Roberts. "Structural Tightncss and Social
Conformin' -A Methodological Note $'ith Theoretical lmplications".
Journal of'('n*s-Cullural Ps.vchologrV,.o l. 10. No. 2. June 1979.
Bourdieu. Pierre. "The Sentiment of Honour in Kabvlc Sociclr"'- Ilonour
ancl Shame I'lte I'ulues o.f .\Iediterranern Sttcie!.t- Editcd b1, J G
Peristianl'. The Unir.ersi{' of Chicago Press. 1966 iginde.
Calhoun, Craig. "Pluralitr'. Promises. and Public Spaccs''. Craig Calhoun:
John McGowan (Editors): Ilonnah ."1.rendat nd the ,\.Iedningo f l\tlitics'.
Universitl' of Minncsota Prcss. Minneapolis- I 997 iqinde.
Campbell. Jennifer D.. "Self-Eslcem and Clarity of the Self-Concept".
Journal of Per.xnalit-v,andS ocial P*,chologt'. Vol. 59. No. 3. 1990..
Clrodoron'. Nancl'. T'he Repntduclion of'trktthering -P.s.vchoonal.vsoisr ul
the Sociolog.t' oJ' ()encler-. Llniversit)' of California Press" Berkelel'. Los
Angelcs. London. 1979
CrcightorrN. lillic R "'RevisitingS hamca nd Guilt Cullurcs:A Fortr'-Year
PilerrmaElc'/''.. //ro^Vr.o l. lit" No 3 Scptcmbc'lr' tvll
( risp. Rogcr i'c Michacl Slotc (Ediiors). 'lntrcrductrun''"I irtue i'.1hit's.
{)ilbrd Unircrgitr Prcss-( ).rfbrd.1 997r qinde.
Daegcr" Il.ichard.( 'it it i trttte,r )(i:,:itr.s(.' iti:euthip, 1.11i'trtttt1\.:7o.l,.. l.l/ No.
.i.. .l*il i(,)9(r
l:'rsr;!.f.i iilcr ()hlrrari. '-Psrchopalht:logr
autl tltc Iurkish F'anrilr. A [jamrtl
51g iCfili Ir'rt$n furalrSi.,". Ji,r ffrrlL,';,! ttitrtti_,";'I. f,'r;itiittit:r;iyi ri lUrit.t-
F.dilcd b.r ('1i,-1i:n l,efii5rha;r rrilii ihc:issi\iance cf'liianc Sunlr. lridi;:lra
[.jnii crsi!r
'l
irrhis.li! i(ur,li,:..iq{)"i ';2i 9ir,d,:
|rrer. Frcdr'1i}, W . "Pa{1i:ms of Elltc Pc!i1ics iti Jtrrkcr''. ['rtlt!it , i '' !i;t ; ;;:
tlir' .\!irit!lc i:,.;.rr. t.rJilud br' (ic<;rgc Lcn,,:ri:ilshi ,funi'rii;ti ir,,'.;.'1;1;,r,'
instilutc tcr Riblir- Poi;;r Rcsearclr.\ V:-r...liirutoni") f' lil?i
[ieiincr, [jrntsi. .\'rrlioirtrltsitPr lloe,rlrrl., oti{,.lot1"'r.-i '.)}i-
Crtrbs. flolrr,rl. "A\rm!!'rain' i:rti.l \luir;;itt' i-lrtr':rr
J, fui lat .sr t1: i1t lti, . ' . i ; i i . r l { ' t ' r l i r i r l r i \ r l i j t . i r rg a, . ! t ' : , '
{illllgan. C'arol., /lrr l)il./<'rntrI ut<."-' lt.".t'tltr'!ttgirttl '!
ltt',r.t tttr,l I! ontctt'.,
i)rt t'!tt{tnertt- Flana rrJi -trrilcrsitvP rcss.( 'ilmtrridge.\ 1a:sachusetts:r.n d
i.ondon l9')'l
Gcrdr'licri.v lauricc. 'l'hc t-niEma oi' (hc (irli. I'ranslulcd hr Noru lr,:o(1.
Polih'Press, l9(,i9
G6kalp. 1*t.
'l'iirk i r,ror'lrsr
'l
t;ri!:r " ilat 'r'tisul (otuks'jl.cn- Inkii;rrr
F.rtar*uvil.s lanbul. I (.,9i
Gr.rattarip. g115\.i r/i .\)iir grriori..:E: drtedb v Svh crc Lotringcr. rnrnslulccbi r
Dnid L. Srlcctv e ('het \\'icncr^S cn'riote\l{ciN. en }'ork- lt)'Xr.
Gtrlcrce. Ardan.
'[ltrkt,"t'de..liieler!n
I'vkoltjik ()rtirttiilt'r.i Bogaziqi
Unrvcrstles\i' :trtni:ii'r istantltl. I()()fr.
Giincq-Alat;r. Ai$e "Soliduritr itr Urban
'l-urkrsh
Fanlih".
'l
ttA'i:h
l;u;ttiltas in
'l
rart.siirori.c d. b1 Gltrricli: R-asui-1Ii alcczck. Pclcr L,.r,tg.
Frankfurt lrn N4ain. l9()ti iqiude .
Hilar. Sclahattrrr"'' FclscfcninB uqlangrcr.D ogu" Korku. Birer'-. ]rr;rio
!;eisvft: I'a.;Itt n. 5 Kitlp. 1983.
Hofstcdc. Gcert. ''Valuc S.r'stems in Fortv Countrics. lnlcrprctation.
Validation and Consequence{sb r Theo4."'.( i-r.,.rs-(
'ullttul ('()ttlnhu!i!)tr\ !t)
Fst't:hrtlogv. Ed b1 l.,ulz H. Eckensberger. \Valter J Lonner. Ypr lt.
Poorlinga.S ucls and Zcitlingcr R V " I-issc lt)7i)i ginde.
Hofstcdc. Gecn. t'ttllurv.t onJ ()rganizulirnrs -Sttt'itl'(rr( ()f lhe' urirul-.
X{cGral -Hill Book Compart_rl., tlndcn. NervY ork. l(X)I .
inglcharl. Roruld '"Trust" lVell-Bcing and Detttocr:tc\''. l)enrtx:ru(.r' uttl
'l'ru.st.Ed.
b1 N{ark E. W;rrcn. Carnbridgc Univcrsitl Press" 1999 iginde
Jxquette. Dan: Sumnr Erkul. "Oprative and Rr:presenlational Social
Thought. Somc Catcgc)rieso f Social Expcricnce in thc T'urkish Villagc' .
ilocetlepe Ilulletnt of Soctul Sc:renr,:uetst d ilurtrurtillc'^sV. ol. 7, nos l-1.
iune-Dcc. .1 975.
Jaqr"D avrd. julia Jary"( 'ol!ins l)i<:tionur.ot ! Sot.iultryl.S ecoudE drtion"
HarpcrCollins. Cilasgou. I 9t)5
Kalrtglbaq;r.( i!dcm. '-lndn'idualistic vs. Rclational Modcls of lv{an- fhc
('ase of an lnten'cnlion Research-"-S truclural ('ha;rgt'itt'!-urkish.\irt:lsrr'.
Ediled br Miibcccel Krrav Indiana Univcrsitv T'urkish Studics. l99l
iqincic.
Ka[rtgrbaqr.( i!dem. "Old-Age Securit-vV alue of Childrcn -Cross-National
SocioeconomicE vidence". ./ournul of (.'nx.s-('tilturull 's.vchttluct'r.' oltttne.
l.l- No.l- March l9lB2.
Kagtgrbaqr. Qifdcm"
''Social Norms and Authoritarianism: A
'hrrkish-
American Conrparison"- Journol o/ l'er*tnolitv and *tc:ial Psvchologt'.
volume 16. No. 3. 1970
Kafrtqrbagr.Q if,dem.K tiItiirtI I'.sikioji KiiIttir Bapluntttdu insan ve..tiIe-
Qevirenler: Qipdern Kaprtqrbagl. ArSc Uskiil. Esin Uzun, Yapr Kredi
Kilhiir Sanat Yarrncrlrk. istanbul. l99tt.
Kalal'cro$u. Ersin. "1960 Sonrasr Tiirk Politik Ha1'atrna Bir Bakrg:
Denrokrasi.N eo-Patrimonvalizmv e istikrar". T'iirki.t'e'dIe'o litik DepiSimve
.\lodemleSnreE. rsin Kala-"-cro$uA. li Yagar Sanbar'.A lfa. istanbul. 20(n.
Kanungo. Rabindra N.. "The Concept of Alienation and In\,oh'ement
Rer,'isited"P. s.vchologicaBl ulletin- Vol. tt6. No. l. 1979.
Kellner. Douglas. .leon Baudrillard l;nnr Jllarxistrt lo Postntoclernism and
Be"wtndP- olifi' Prcss.1 99L
Kitavama. Shinobu. Hazel Rose Markus. Hisava Matsumoto. "Culture.
Self. and Emotion: A Cultural Perspectiveo n "Self-Conscious"E motions",
Self-Conscious Endions -The Ps.vcfutlogt qf Shante, Guilt,
F)nborrassnrertt, tutd Pride-- Editcd [' June Price Tangnel'. Kurt W.
Fischer. Forervord b1' Joseph Campos. The Guilford Press. Neu' York.
London. 1995 iqinde.
Len'is. J. David: Andreu' Weigert. "Trust as a Social Realiqr"'. Social
F'orces-V ol, 63:4. June 1985.
Louden. Robert B." "On Some Vices of Virtue Ethics" Itrlue Ethics. Edited
b1' Roger Crisp and Michael Slote. Oxford Universit]' Press. Oxford" 1997
iginde.
Lukcs. Steven: "lntroduction"" Emile Durkheim. The Rules of Strciological
Alethotl- Edited with an Introduction by Steven Lukes. Translated b.\'W. D
Halls" The Free Press. Nen'York. 1982.
Martin. Curtis H.. Bruce Stronach- Polilics F,ast ond ltr/est A Compari.son
t1f Japanese and British Political Culture-. M. E. Sharpe. Armonk. New
York. 1992.
Matsumoto. David Tsutomu Kudoh. Sachiko Takeuchi. "Changing
Patterns of Individualism and Collectivism in the United States and Japan".
Cullure and Psvchologv. Vol. 2. 1996.
Mauss. M., Gi.ft -F'orms and Funclions of Exchange in Archaic Societies-.
Translated by lan Cunnison. Introduction b1'E E. Evans-Pritchard, The
Free Press. Glencoe. Illinois. 1954.
Mautner. Thomas {Ed.). The Penguin Diclionar.v of Philosoph.v. Penguin
Books. 1997.
Nliller" Joan G.: David M. Bersoff. "Cultural lnlluences on the Moral Status
of Reciprocitv and the Discounting of Endogenous Motir.ation''.
['crxtrtulil.r'ottdS ociulP s.vcholtryl'RulletiVn-o l. 2().N o. 5" October1 99{.
Miller. Joan G.: David N{. Berso{L "Culturc and Moral Judgrncnt: llol Arc
Conflicts Bet*een Juslice and lnterpersonal Responsibilities Resolrcd'l".
./o trrnal of Per sona li t.va' nd Socia l Ps.t:choolg .v.V ol. 62" No. .1. I 992.
Miller. Joan G.: David M. Bersoff: Robin 1.. llanrood" "Pcrccptions of
SocialR esponsibilitiesin India and in the tJnitedS tates:M oral Imperatives
or PcrsonalD ectsions'1",.I ournal of' Per*nralifi' ond Strcial Ps.v'chttlog,t'.
Vol. 5tt. No. l. | 990.
Murphr. Patrick E.. "Character and Virtue Ethics in lnlernational
Marketing:A n Agendaf or Managers.R esearcherasn d Educators".. lounrol
ttl Bu,sinesEst hics. 18. 1999.
C)z-en. Skii. Btirokrutik Ktilttir I I.tinetsel I)eperlerin Tirlumsal
'l'
e n e l I e ri -. TODAIE Yavrnlan. Ankara. I 99(r.
Ozlern. Dopan. Si.v'aseBt,i lim ve T'arih llilinci. intcitap Ya1'rnlan" 1999.
Istanbul
Phalet. Karen. Willem Clae-r's:" A Comparati\€ Studl of Turkish and
Belgian Youth". Jourual of Crc:;-s-('ultural Ps.v,chologr.V'.o l. 2.1. No. 3.
Septcmbe1r 993.
Pitt-Rivcrs. Julian. "Honour and Social Status". Ilonour ancl Shone 7'he
lhlues o./' ;\lediterronean Socieh. Edited by J. G. Peristianl'. The
Unir.ersino' f ChicagoP ress.1 966.
h'e" Lucian W. rvith Mary W. P-veA- sian I'ou,era nd Politics -The Cultural
I)imensiotr o.f Authorit.v-. The Belknap Press of Han'ard Unirersitr Press.
CambridgeM. assachusettsL"o ndon- 198-5.
h'e. Lucian W.- T'heS pirit of ('hinese I'olilics -,1 Ps.vchoculturaSl tudv o./
the Authorih' (''risi.s in Political f)evelopmen!-. The M.l T. Press"
Cambridge. l96li.
Rasulv-Paleczek Gabriele. "Some Remarks On the Studv of Household
Composition and Intra-Famih' Relations in Rural and Urban Turkel"'.
Turkish l;otni lies in Transition. Gabriele Resulv-Paleczek (ed.)- Peter Lang.
Frankfurt am Main. 1996 igindc.
R1'crofl.C harles. ,4 Criticql Dictionarv of P:;.vchoonalvs'r^Sse. condE dition.
Pcnguin Books. London. 1995.
Sampson. Eduard E.- "Individualization and Domination: Undermining
The Social Bond"" Grouth ond Progress in Cntss-(lultural Ps.vcholog.v.
Edited b1' Qigdem Kagrtgibasi. Swets North America Inc./Benwn Srvets &
Zeitlinger B. V./Lisse. 1987 iqinde.
l . ; r r i t : l r . , , \ l ; \ '15;1r_ S, ; r r t { } .1lh i i r r r le l l l l i ; . t " A, . " , " r ; i i . t . i ! , i r : , l } i . i t : ! t , : t k
i i t , t ; , , i t , . . , . . . , ; . l : ; . . . . : . . , i 1 1 : i ( . t : t l ? a j ! j r { ! { r : i : i - ( , i ' i -
Sci r ; i l r i r . ' i \ r i r r r i : r l - - rs l , ' i . , 1" ' r ' i1l i r : t iPi : : i r i , . l l l t i , r ; i i r i ' t i i l i ; i *cr i tc t . ' - r ; tc
, lnd i r \ t f cept l ( x r ( ) l l i l ! l ( i ( r t ! ! t t t ' . ' r t l t t t i ' i t iut l ! t i t ' ! ' l t t t , t?t . ' t i t 7t . t ti ' i sh
I t/lugar- [diirU 5r' i'lrul :rirr;rng. i i.rc f]t-rritclr i:'rcst l i l i n l i r i g d t l i i .
t-Lrriiirrrjgciirr\r- i \.i"i lcindc.
) \ h i l r i \ \ ' 1 i l t i . -) l . i .
' i i r
\ 4 t s i o n ' , r n t t nt \ r r n u ( ' . i r r l r r c i ' . l i r r r , r , Ectrti-d h r :
R.,tgtr i lrrt; lrri4l
' . r l - " , ' qt , r1a. 1. t t .l i:r r i ! ! - .1: . \ l \ i r i . ! j l1 PfirS:.. {iribrd. 19t7
,cindu
S;hi::r'ir. S l i * l i i r r r il "
i { C i l t r i ' , i i i i i l . i t : t r : t , t
I . i ' ) r ,
Sinaitogiu. Str;r; /);. r '
i rlst I
' l url,, l ilrr.r i iiur -(,i) l it,t,i; i r l,nr {..'ri l i,ir.ic a l}d Prr}poscd
, t i i - t 'u. t : .| , . i i t , : , . ' l l r s r i . . / , , ,1i ,,1. t : t t i i 2i . i iO l . J r i i iC
! i :i t i t t t t t i :r i r t .'i ltri
-[
.rrtil K rtrUtttr-r !';rr rltiitir .\itkaru'
i:r::!rr'\'. lclrn ii "
'Cro-cc-Crritrrril{! trrilcrsllllr of Social-ltlorll
I)lt';li-.ptrt;ii1A I riirc,rlR r.:r'icuo l-K ohlr.*rgiitnR csciirch"] 't.11:l;ttlrtgtt'ol
i l ; r l ! , . : : ' rl.' ) 8: . Vol ( r?,a lo2 )
iitri r:rltukis . \ uniiis;" ''A tttbrgiitius i)crtrocr:rc_ru' nd thc f thics ol
PSlCh. r i i l t tai , \Si \{.' l t i l i , s r ,1t !1tL t t ;d, : l , t { t t t i( ' r t l i t t - tnt . \ul l l No. 2. l9t l7
St i r i ing.i ?aui I : .nr ine{ - inarLni r rcr r ' l rogl r' fr' hcos; r rgS pruscs,V l l lagers"
N,{ir.'rrrrtiKl lnihip a!td
'l'in1c''. 't'trl,i.:ii
l;tint;iit,.srr y 'l't^otr\i!i()tfri.a trriele
Rirsrrir-l-'irlcr:z{er:td .i.P otelL altg i'ranklurt anl il.lain.l 99t! rqiildc
Tez-cl\., r[ivl Si;z;ri.l '.'rtstrlnrrtlr,t'rti:lrt iirii, a l)t:urttkrttsi lAtt.str.l\ i'irr.rcr'l'e
'l
orilt 1n:,lun- \'lrr rml !lllzrrl;llan. i\.4elihY iiriisc'n"L ibcrtc Ylt rnlan.
fulk:lril l1r,){1.
1ezrc. F-rdogln-, -i,,{.r}r?.I\i/urk uA'u( (ient! l'.sa.tlertl-3 c5inciB asr. Bcta
Y;ti'rnhn. lsllnbul. l99S
-Irrandrs.
iiarn C.. Chrrslopticr \,lcCusker. C. ilarn fiui ''Multrmcthod
Probcsi if'lrlCiridrtuiisttta nd Collr:ctittsttt'-".l ,rrtnrti ttf l>{r>

Thank you for copying data from http://www.arastirmax.com