You are here

Home » Content

Sivil-Asker İşbirliği Uygulamaları ve Askerî Etkililik: “Yeni” Bir Kuvvet Çarpanı mı?

Civil-Military Cooperation Practices and Military Effectiveness: A “New” Force Multiplier?

Journal Name:

  • Kara Harp Okulu Bilim Dergisi

Publication Year:

  • 2015

Key Words:

Keywords (Original Language):

Author Name
Abstract (2. Language): 
The main aim of this article is to examine the relationship between military effectiveness and Civil-Military Cooperation (CIMIC) practices, getting more and more widespread with the end of the Cold War. CIMIC practices, which have maintained their presence ever since 2nd World War, have gained impetus for the last two decades as a result of radical transformation in the role of civilians on the theather of operations. Thus, the planners aiming at reaching end state by means of as minimum input as possible have began to exploit CIMIC that is part of non-kinetic elements as a force multiplier. This article, from this point forth, examines the relationship between CIMIC and military effectiveness by means of a model and based upon Bosnia, Kosovo, and Afghanistan case studies. The main thesis of the article is that: CIMIC practices have positive contributions upon military effectiveness provided they are well-planned and executed in a coordinated manner.
Bookmark/Search this post with
Abstract (Original Language): 
Bu makalenin amacı, Soğuk Savaş’ın sona ermesi ile birlikte giderek yaygınlaşan Sivil-Asker İşbirliği (SAİ) uygulamalarının askerî etkililik ile ilişkisini incelemektir. İkinci Dünya Savaşı’ndan bu yana varlığını sürdüren SAİ uygulamaları, sivillerin harekât ortamındaki rollerinde yaşanan köklü dönüşümün etkisiyle özellikle son 20 yılda ağırlığını artırmıştır. Böylece mümkün olan asgari girdi ile istenen son duruma ulaşmayı hedefleyen planlamacılar, kinetik olmayan unsurlar arasında yer alan SAİ uygulamalarından bir kuvvet çarpanı olarak istifade etmeye başlamışlardır. Makalede bu süreçten hareketle SAİ uygulamalarının askerî etkililik ile ilişkisi, geliştirilen model üzerinden ve Bosna-Hersek, Kosova ve Afganistan örnek olayları temelinde irdelenmiştir. Makalenin temel savı, iyi planlanan ve koordineli şekilde icra edilen SAİ uygulamalarının askerî etkililik düzeyine olumlu katkı sağladığıdır.
FULL TEXT (PDF): 
PDF icon arastirmax-sivil-asker-isbirligi-uygulamalari-askeri-etkililik-yeni-bir-kuvvet-carpani-mi.pdf
  • 2
109
139
  • Turkish

REFERENCES

References: 

ACBAR policy brief: NGOs concerns and recommendations on civil-military relations. (2002). http://reliefweb.int/report/afghanistan/acbar-policy-brief-ngos-concerns... adresinden alınmıştır. (Erişim Tarihi: 14 Nisan 2015).
An Agenda for Peace: Preventive Diplomacy, Peacemaking, and Peace-keeping. (1992). http://www.unrol.org/files/A_47_277.pdf adresinden alınmıştır. (Erişim Tarihi: 21 Mart 2015).
AJP 3.4.9 (2013). Allied Joint Doctrine for Civil – Military Cooperation.
Ankersen, C. (2014). The Politics of Civil-Military Cooperation: Canada in Bosnia, Kosovo, and Afghanistan, Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan.
Aristotle, (1988). The Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Barry, J. ve A.Jefferys. (2002). A bridge too far: Aid agencies and the military in humanitarian response, Humanitarian Practice Network Paper, Vol.37, January.
Bauman, Z. (2001). Parçalanmış Hayat, Postmodern Ahlâk Denemeleri (Çev. İsmail Türkmen). İstanbul: Ayrıntı Yayınevi.
Beeres, R. ve P.Fenema. (2008). Assessing Civil-Military Performance: Toward a Research Agenda. İçinde S.Rietjens ve M.Bollen (Ed.), Managing Civil-Military Cooperation: A 24/7 Joint Effort for Stability. Hampshire: Ashgate.
Biddle, S. (2004). Military Power: Explaining Victory and Defeat in Modern Battle, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Bollen, M. (2008). Refugees in Albania: A Case of Civil-Military Cooperation, İçinde S.Rietjens ve M.Bollen (Ed.), Managing Civil-Military Cooperation: A 24/7 Joint Effort for Stability. Hampshire: Ashgate.
Braem, Y. (2008). Managing territories with rival brothers: the geopolitical stakes of military-humanitarian relations, İçinde C.Ankersen (Ed.), Civil-Military Cooperation in Post-Conflict Operations: Emerging Theory and Practice. New York: Routledge.
Brahimi Report. (2000). http://www.un.org/en/ga/search/view_doc.asp?symbol =A/55/305 adresinden alınmıştır. (Erişim Tarihi: 13 Şubat 2015).
Braun, M.A. (2005). Civil-military cooperation as a vital part in the stabilization-process in Afghanistan: How its meaning different within ceratin deployed military actors?, Seminar paper, Potsdam University.
132 | Öztürk
Brooks, R.A. (2007). Introduction: The Impact of Culture, Society, Institutions, and International Forces on Military Effectiveness, İçinde R.A.Brooks ve E.A.Stanley (Ed.), Creating Military Power: The Sources of Military Effectiveness. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Dorn, W. ve M.Varey. (2008). Fatally flawed: The rise and demise of the “three-block war” concept in Canada, International Journal, Autumn.
Dupuy, T.N. (1979). Numbers, prediction, and war: Using history to evaluate combat factors and predict the outcome of battles, New York: Bobbs-Merrill.
Durch, W.J. (2010). Supporting Peace: The End, PRISM, Vol.2, No.1
Egnell, R. (2008). Between Reluctance and Necessity: The Utility of Military Force in Humanitarian and Development Operations, Small Wars and Insurgencies, Vol.19, No.3
Erickson, E. (2007). Ottoman Army Effectiveness in World War I: A Comparative Study, New York: Routledge.
Flavin, W. (2004). Civil Military Operations: Afghanistan, Observations on Civil Military Operations During the First Year of Operation Enduring Freedom, Carlisle: US Army War College.
Flint, E. (2001). Civil Affairs: Soldiers Building Bridges, İçinde D.S.Gordon ve F.H.Toase (Ed.), Aspects of Peackeeping. London: Frank Cass
Franke, V. ve L.Heinecken. (2001). Adjusting to Pecae: Military Values in a Cross-National Comparison, Armed Forces and Society, Vol.27, No.4.
Franke, V. (2006). The Peacebuilding Dilemma: Civil-Military Cooperation in Stability Operations, International Journal of Peace Studies, Vol.11, No.2.
Galtung, J. (1985). Twenty-Five Years of Peace Research: Ten Challenges and Some Responses, Journal of Peace Research, Vol.22, No.2
Gaspar, C. (2011). NATO’s Strategic Concept, İçinde L.N.Rodrigues ve V.Dubovyk (Ed.), Perceptions of NATO and the New Strategic Concept. Amsterdam: IOS Press.
Gordon, S. (2001). Understanding the Priorities for Civil-Military Co-operation, The Journal of Humanitarian Assistance, http://www.jha.ac/articles/a068.htm adresinden alınmıştır. (Erişim tarihi: 09 Mayıs 2015).
Gourlay, C. (2000). Partners Apart: Managing Civil-Military Co-operation in Humanitarian Interventions, İçinde K.Vignad (Ed.), Peacekeeping: Evolution or Extinction? Geneva: UNIDIR
Kara Harp Okulu Bilim Dergisi, Aralık 2015, 25 (2), 111-139. | 133
Gray, S. (2005). Another Bloody Century, London: Weidenfeld&Nicolson.
Jakobsen, P.V. (2005). PRTs in Afghanistan: Succesful but not Sufficient, DIIS Report, Vol.6, Copenhagen: Danish Institute for International Studies.
Johannson, T. (2011). The effectiveness of CIMIC in peace operations: From the view of the local people, Master’s Thesis, Uppsala University.
Kasselmann, H.J. (2012). Civil-Military Cooperation: A Way to Resolve Complex Crisis Situations, PRISM, Vol.4, No.1
Khalid, M., S.F.Wahidi, B.Rietjens ve M.Bollen. (2008). Enhancing the Afghan Footprint: Civil-Military Cooperation and Local Participation, İçinde S.Rietjens ve M.Bollen (Ed.), Managing Civil-Military Cooperation: A 24/7 Joint Effort for Stability. Hampshire: Ashgate.
Klem, B. ve S.Laar. (2008). Pride and Prejudice: An Afghan and Liberian Case Study, İçinde S.Rietjens ve M.Bollen (Ed.), Managing Civil-Military Cooperation: A 24/7 Joint Effort for Stability. Hampshire: Ashgate.
Korb, L.J. (1984). National Security Strategy: Choices and Limits, İçinde S.J..Cimbala (Ed.) How Well Can We Fight? For How Long? New York: Praeger.
Krulak, C. (1997). The three block war: Fighting in urban areas, Vital Speech of the Day, Vol.64, No.5
Küskü, F. (1999). Yöneten–Yönetilen İlişkisinde Güven: Ampirik Bir İnceleme. Amme İdaresi Dergisi, Sayı 32.
Landon, J.J. (2008). Civil-Military Cooperation, İçinde L.Wentz (Ed.), Lessons from Bosnia: The IFOR Experience. Washington: CCRP
Lavigne, J.P. (2001). “Imece - a Turkish tradition”, SFOR Informer#123, October 3, 2001
Mazurkiewics, A. (2014). Does CIMIC Make Sense? Critical Analysis of Civil-Military Cooperation, CII Analyses Bulletin no 4/2014.
McNerney, M. (2008). CIMIC on the edge: Afghanistan and the evolution of civil-military operations, İçinde C.Ankersen (Ed.), Civil-Military Cooperation in Post-Conflict Operations: Emerging Theory and Practice. New York: Routledge.
Metcalfe, V., S.Haysom ve S.Gordon. (2012). Trends and challenges in humanitarian civil-military coordination: A review of the literature, Humanitarian Policy Group Working Paper, May.
Millett, A.R, W.Murray ve K.H.Watman. (1988). The Effectiveness of Military Organizations. İçinde A.R.Millett ve W.Murray (Ed.), Military Effectiveness, Volume 1: The First World War, Boston: Allen and Unwin.
134 | Öztürk
Mockaitis, T.R. (2004). Civil-Military Cooperation in Peace Operations: The Case of Kosovo. Carlisle: Strategic Studies Institute of the US Army War College.
Moskos, C.C., J.A.Williams ve DR.Segal. (2000). Armed Forces after the Cold War, İçinde C.C.Moskos, J.A.Williams, D.R.Segal (Ed.), The Postmodern Military: Armed Forces after the Cold War. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
NATO Backgrounder, “Civil Support for Military Operations and Emergency Planning”, January 2008.
Nielsen, S.C. (2005). Civil-Military Relations Theory and Military Effectiveness, Public Administration and Management, Vol.10, No.2.
Philips, W. (1998). Civil-Military Cooperation: Vital to Peace Implementation in Bosnia, NATO Review, 46:1
Rana, R. (2004). Contemporary challenges in the civil-military relationship: Complementary or incompatibility?, IRRC September, Vol.86, No.855.
Rietjens, B. (2008a). Performing in Kabul: Explaining Civil-Military Cooperation in Stabilization and Reconstruction Missions, İçinde S.Rietjens ve M.Bollen (Ed.), Managing Civil-Military Cooperation: A 24/7 Joint Effort for Stability. Hampshire: Ashgate.
_______ (2008b). Providing Relief: The Case of the Dutch Engineers in Kosovo, İçinde S.Rietjens ve M.Bollen (Ed.) Managing Civil-Military Cooperation: A 24/7 Joint Effort for Stability. Hampshire: Ashgate.
Sambanis, N. (2007). Short-Term and Long-Term Effects of United Nations Peace Operations, World Bank Group Policy Research Working Papers, April.
Savage, O.A.J. (2008). Yes, but is it peacebuilding? Evaluating civil-military cooperation in Afghanistan, İçinde C.Ankersen (Ed.), Civil-Military Cooperation in Post-Conflict Operations: Emerging Theory and Practice, New York: Routledge.
Schwiering, T. (2013). CIMIC Competence Center, Netherlands: CCOE.
Smith, R. (2006). The Utility of Force: The Art of War in the Modern World, London: Penguin Books.
Stavridis, J.G. (2011). The Comprehensive Approach in Afghanistan, PRISM, Vol.2, No.2
Studer, M. (2001). The IRRC and civil-military relations in armed conflict, IRRC June, Vol.83, No.842.
Kara Harp Okulu Bilim Dergisi, Aralık 2015, 25 (2), 111-139. | 135
Talmadge, E.R. (2011). Explaining Military Effectiveness: Political Intervention and Battlefield Performance, PhD dissertation, Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Voget, B.G. (2008). Civil-military cooperation of the German armed forces: theoretical approach and contemporary practice in Kosovo, İçinde C.Ankersen (Ed.), Civil-Military Cooperation in Post-Conflict Operations: Emerging Theory and Practice. New York: Routledge.
Weezel, S. (2011). CIMIC Concept and Capabilities: Research into the CIMIC Operationalisation of Nations, Enschede: CCOE
Weger, M. (2008). International Policing Missions: A Framework for Effective Civil-Military Cooperation, İçinde S.Rietjens ve M.Bollen (Ed.), Managing Civil-Military Cooperation: A 24/7 Joint Effort for Stability. Hampshire: Ashgate.
Weinberger, N. (2002). Civil-Military Coordination in Peacebuilding: The Challenge in Afghanistan, Journal of International Affairs, Vol.55, No.2.
Weiss, T. ve C.Collins. (1996). Humanitarian Challenges and Intervention, Oxford: Westview Press.
Zaalberg, T.B. (2008). The Historical Origins of Civil-Military Cooperation, İçinde S.Rietjens ve M.Bollen (Ed.), Managing Civil-Military Cooperation: A 24/7 Joint Effort for Stability. Hampshire: Ashgate.

Thank you for copying data from http://www.arastirmax.com