You are here

Home » Content

BİNA TASARIMINDA DEĞERLENDİRMEYE İLİŞKİN DENEYSEL BİR ÇALIŞMA

AN EXPERIMENTAL STUDY OF EVALUATION IN BUILDING DESIGN

Journal Name:

  • Orta Doğu Teknik Üniversitesi Mimarlık Fakültesi Dergisi

Publication Year:

  • 1976
Author Name
Bookmark/Search this post with
Abstract (Original Language): 
Bu yazıda mimar ve mimar olamayanların, mimarlık tasarımlarının değerlendirilmesindeki davranışları incelenmekte, karar verici grupların düşünce birliği düzeyleri, tasarıma ilişkin verilerin nitelik ve niceliği, ve karar vericilerin meslekleri arasındaki ikişkiler deneysel yolla araştırılmaktadır. Bu amaçla düzenlenen deneylerin ilkinde veri niceliğinin, tatil evlerinin seçimindeki rolü incelenmiş, istatistik analizlerle, aşağıdaki sonuçlara varılmıştır: 1. Mimar olmayanlar, kendilerine sadece tasarım çizimleri verildiğinde birbirleriyle mimarlara oranla daha çok düşünce birliğine varmakta, 2. Yine mimar olmayanlar, tatil evi çizimleri ve ek bilgi verildiğinde ( örneğin, yapım ve işletme maliyetleri, alanları) hemen hemen mimarlarla aynı sonuçlara varmakta, 3. Mimar olmayan karar vericiler, kendilerine çizim ve ek bilgi verildiğinde en az mimarlar kadar düşünce birliğine varmaktadırlar. Yine sonuç olarak, gelecekte düşünce birliği düzeyinin, tasarımların değerlendirilmesinde ( örneğin, mimarlık yarışmaları) geçerli ölçüt olarak kabul edilmesi gereği savunulmaktadır.
FULL TEXT (PDF): 
PDF icon arastrmx_290_2_pp_49-59.pdf
  • 1
49-59
  • English

REFERENCES

References: 

ABDELRAHMAN, S. "An Experiment to Compare the Response of
Architects and Laymen to Two Dimensional Architectural
Drawings." Unpublished Report, Department of Architecture
and Building Science, University of Strathclyde, 1974.
ABERCROMBIE, M.L.J. Perception and Construction. Design Methods
in Architecture, ed.s G. Broadbent and A.Ward,
Architectural Association Paper No.4; London: Lund
Humphries, 1969.
APPLEYARD, D. Professional Priorities for Environmental
Psychology. Architectural Psychology: Proceedings
of the Lund Conference, ed.by R. Küller, Strondsburg,
Pennsylvania: Dowden, Hutchinson and Ross, 1973.
BAILEY, J.M. Letter to the Editor. The Architect's Journal,
19 June 1974.
CAMPBELL, S. Architectural Values as a Measure of Design
Decision-Making. Proceedings of the EDRA 3 Conference,
ed. by W.J. Mitchell, Los Angeles: UCLA, 1972.
CANTER, D. The Place of Architectural Psychology. Proceedings
of the Architectural Psychology Conference 1970, ed.by
B. Honikman, London: RIBA Publications Ltd., 1971.
COLEMAN, J.R. A Computer Program Package for User Participation
in Housing Design, The Third International Design
Activity Conference Preprints, London, 1973.
COLLINS, P. Architectural Judgement. London: Faber and Faber,
1971.
CRAIK, K. The Comprehension of the Every Physical Environment.
Journal of the American Institute of Planners, v.34,
n. 1, 1968, pp.29-37.
CRAUN, R. Visual Determinants of Preference for Dwelling
Environs. Proceedings of the EDRA 1 Conference,
ed. by H. Sanoff and S. Cohn, N.C. State Un., Raleigh,
N.C., 1970.
FLEMING, M.C. Building Decisions and Economic Appraisal
Techniques in Practice. Value in Building, ed. by
G.H. Hutton and A.D.G. Devonald, London: Applied
Science Publishers, 1973.
GÂRLING, T. Studies in Visual Perception of Architectural
Spaces and Rooms; V. Aesthetic Preferences, Scandinavian
Journal of Psychology, v.13, 1972, pp. 222-227.
HORMANN, A. Machine-aided Evaluation of Alternative Designs.
Proceedings of the EDRA 3 Conference, ed. by
W.J. Mitchell, UCLA, Los Angeles, 1972.
KAPLAN, S. and WENDT, J.S. Preference and the Visual
Environment: Complexity and Some Alternatives.
Proceedings of the EDRA 3 Conference,ed.by W.J.
Mitchell, UCLA, Los Angeles, 1972.
LAU, J.J.H. Differences Between Full-size and Scale-model
Rooms in the Assessment of Lighting Quality.
Proceedings of the Architectural Psychology Conference,
1969, ed. by D.V. Canter, London: RIBA Publications
Ltd., 1970.
MANNHEIM, M. Reaching Decisions About Technological Projects
with Social Consequences: A Normative Model. Design
Research Bag, June 1972.
MARKMAN, R. Sensation-seeking and Environmental Preference.
Proceedings of the EDRA 2 Conference, ed. by J. Archie
and C. Eastman, Carnegie-Mellon Un., 1970.
MAVER, T.W. , Design Paradigms, Design Aids and Design Decisions.
International Conference on Computers in Architecture,
Preprints, York: University of York, 1972.
MIKELLIDES, B. Evaluation of Holiday Chalets by Architects
and Laymen. Synthesis 2z Architectural Research Review,
Oxford Polytechnic, April 1973.
PAYNE, I. Pupillary Responses to Architectural Stimuli.
Proceedings of the Architectural Psychology Conference,
1969, ed. by D.V. Canter, London: RIBA Publications
Ltd., 1970.
RAPOPORT, A. An Approach to the Study of Environmental
Quality. Proceedings of the EDRA 1 Conference,
ed by H. Sanoff and S. Cohn, N.C. State Un.,
Raleigh, N.C., 1970.
SANOFF, H. and SAWHNEY, M. Residential Livability : A Study
of User Attitudes Towards Their Residential Environment.
Proceedings of the EDRA 3 Conference, ed. by W.J.
Mitchell, Los Angeles, UCLA, 1972.
SEATON, R.W. Validity and Reliability of Ratings of Simulated
Buildings. Proceedings of the EDRA 3 Conference,
ed. by W.J. Mitchell, Los Angeles: UCLA, 1972.
STRINGER, P. A Rationale for Participation. Design
Participation, ed. by N. Cross, London: Academy
Editions, 1972.
WOOLS, R.M. The Assessment of Room Friendliness. Proceedings
of the Architectural Psychology Conference, 1969,
ed. by D.V. Canter, London: RIBA Publications Ltd.,
1970.
ZUBE, E.H. Evaluation - of Environment, of Change and of the
Designer's Underlying Assumptions. The Third
International Design Activity Conference Preprints,
London, 1973.

Thank you for copying data from http://www.arastirmax.com